5 Best Substitute For Brown Mustard

Brown Mustard Substitute

Mustard, particularly the brown variety, holds a place of esteem in the culinary arts for its robust and spicy flavor that can elevate a wide range of dishes. This pungent condiment, derived from the seeds of the mustard plant, offers a delightful mix of heat and tanginess, setting it apart from other seasoning agents. However, certain situations like unavailability, dietary restrictions, or a desire for a different flavor profile might necessitate finding a fitting substitute for brown mustard.

This article presents a definitive guide on the best substitutes for brown mustard, discussing their individual characteristics, usage, and nutritional profiles. Each substitute has been meticulously selected, considering factors like flavor compatibility, accessibility, and potential contribution to the overall taste of a dish. While each substitute has its unique offerings, they all share the capacity to fill in for brown mustard while adding a new dimension to your culinary creations. Read on to discover these exciting alternatives, their application in various recipes, and when each one might be the best choice.

What is Brown Mustard?

Brown mustard, also known as Indian mustard, is a type of mustard seed with a more pungent and spicy flavor compared to its yellow counterpart. It’s the key ingredient in many types of mustard condiments, particularly Dijon and spicy brown mustard. Its seeds are used whole for pickling, ground in Indian and other Asian cuisines, or processed into a paste for condiments. The heat and flavor of brown mustard make it a favorite choice for chefs and home cooks worldwide.

Read More  9 Best Substitute For Walnut Oil

Suggested Substitutes For Brown Mustard

  1. Yellow Mustard
  2. Dijon Mustard
  3. Horseradish
  4. Wasabi
  5. Turmeric and Honey Combination

Best Substitutes For Brown Mustard

As each kitchen adventure requires unique flavors and ingredients, it’s important to understand how each potential substitute aligns with your culinary needs. Let’s explore the top five alternatives for brown mustard, considering their unique flavor profiles, and their potential impact on your dishes.

Yellow Mustard

Yellow Mustard, often called American mustard, is a popular brown mustard substitute. It’s less spicy and has a milder, tangy flavor that contrasts with the robust, fiery nature of brown mustard. Yellow mustard is a blend of white mustard seeds, turmeric, vinegar, water, and salt. The turmeric gives it its vibrant yellow color and contributes to its unique flavor profile.

Yellow mustard can seamlessly replace brown mustard in recipes that require a slightly milder heat and vibrant tang. The bright yellow color might also visually enhance certain dishes. However, it’s crucial to consider that the pungency and heat level will be lower, possibly affecting the overall flavor of spicy dishes.

Dijon Mustard

Dijon mustard is another excellent substitute for brown mustard. It originates from Dijon, a city in Burgundy, France. The smooth and creamy texture of Dijon mustard is a result of the finely ground brown mustard seeds used in its making. Its flavor is sophisticated and complex, offering a smooth, slightly spicy, and tangy taste.

Dijon mustard can replace brown mustard in recipes that require a smoother texture and a slightly less pungent taste. Its flavor is more subtle than brown mustard, which might work well for recipes that require a delicate mustard flavor. However, it’s worth noting that Dijon mustard is generally more expensive than brown mustard.

Read More  9 Best Substitute For Hungarian Wax Peppers


Horseradish, a root vegetable known for its pungent and spicy flavor, is another suitable replacement for brown mustard. Though it’s not a direct match, horseradish’s strong, spicy flavor can mimic the heat provided by brown mustard.

Horseradish is perfect for dishes that require an intense, sharp, and spicy flavor. It’s a common ingredient in cocktail sauces and can replace brown mustard in sandwiches, dips, and dressings. However, its potent flavor can be overwhelming, so it’s advised to use it sparingly.


Wasabi, often associated with Japanese cuisine, can also substitute brown mustard. This root offers a strong heat that quickly dissipates, leaving a sweet aftertaste. Though wasabi’s flavor profile is quite distinct, it can still serve as a brown mustard replacement in specific contexts.

It’s best to use wasabi as a brown mustard substitute in dishes that can accommodate its unique flavor, such as sushi or seafood dishes. Its intense heat can replicate the pungency of brown mustard, but its sweetness might slightly alter the dish’s overall flavor.

Turmeric and Honey Combination

An interesting and creative substitute for brown mustard is a combination of turmeric and honey. Turmeric provides the mustardy taste and vibrant color, while honey adds a touch of sweetness that can balance the pungent turmeric flavor.

This combo works best as a brown mustard substitute in marinades, dressings, or any recipe that requires a sweet, tangy touch. However, it doesn’t have the heat that brown mustard brings, which may affect the spiciness level of certain dishes.

Substitutes for Brown Mustard: Nutritional Profile

Nutritional values can vary significantly among these substitutes. Here’s a comparison of their nutritional content per ¼ cup:

Read More  7 Best Substitute For Sun Dried Tomatoes
GlutenCaloriesFat (g)Carbs (g)Fiber (g)Protein (g)
Yellow MustardNo603523
Dijon MustardNo804634
Turmeric & HoneyNo24016421

*Values are approximate

Concluding Thoughts

Choosing the perfect substitute for brown mustard depends largely on the specific needs of your recipe, your palate, and your dietary restrictions. While no substitute can precisely replicate the unique flavor of brown mustard, many can bring their unique touch to a dish. Experimenting with different alternatives can lead to surprising and delicious outcomes. The kitchen, after all, is a playground for flavor exploration. Remember to keep the heat, tang, and color in mind when choosing your brown mustard substitute, and above all, enjoy the process of discovery!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *