9 Best Substitutes for Biscuit Cutter

Biscuit Cutter Substitute

A biscuit cutter is a specialized kitchen tool designed for one primary purpose: to create uniformly shaped biscuits from dough. Typically crafted from metal or plastic, its circular design and sharp edges facilitate the easy slicing of biscuit dough, while its top handle offers a convenient grip. While these features make it a handy gadget for bakers, the tool is not an absolute necessity. In fact, there are numerous household items and DIY techniques that can effectively replace a traditional biscuit cutter, offering similar, and sometimes even superior, results.

This comprehensive guide explores the best substitutes for a biscuit cutter, ensuring you never find yourself in a biscuit-baking bind. From the ubiquitous glass or mug to the creative use of your own hands, we will examine the pros and cons of each alternative. The article aims to arm you with the knowledge and confidence to make biscuits like a pro, irrespective of whether you own a specialized cutter or not. In a pinch or just eager to try something new, these substitutes will keep your biscuit game strong.

What is a Biscuit Cutter?

A biscuit cutter is a small, circular kitchen tool, traditionally made of metal or plastic, specifically designed to cut dough into perfect biscuit shapes. Its sharp edge makes it easy to slice through dough, while its top handle offers excellent grip. Some designs even incorporate scalloped edges for decorative purposes. However, while handy, a biscuit cutter is not indispensable. Your culinary creativity can achieve similar, if not better, results.

Quick List of Substitutes For Biscuit Cutter

  • Glass or Mug
  • Cookie Cutter
  • Mason Jar Lid
  • Canning Ring
  • Sharp Knife
  • Wine Glass
  • Spoons
  • Aluminum Foil Mold
  • Hands (Yes, your very own)

Best Substitutes For Biscuit Cutter

While there are multiple substitutes, each comes with its unique set of pros and cons. Understanding these will help you make an educated choice, leading to biscuits that will make even your grandma proud.

Read More  9 Best Substitute For Ziti Pasta

Glass or Mug

First, let’s explore the ubiquitous glass or mug. Nearly every household has one, and its circular opening makes it an ideal biscuit-cutter stand-in. The downside? Unlike specialized biscuit cutters, glasses and mugs don’t have a sharp edge. This could lead to biscuits that are less than perfectly shaped.

However, with a bit of technique, you can mitigate this. For instance, you can coat the edge of the glass with flour, giving it a non-stick property that aids in cutting. Also, a quick downward press and twist motion can result in cleaner cuts.

Lastly, if you’re worried about hygiene, ensure the glass or mug is thoroughly washed and dried before using it. You can even dip it in boiling water to ensure it’s sterilized.

Cookie Cutter

Onto the versatile cookie cutter. This is an excellent alternative for those with a well-stocked kitchen. Cookie cutters often come in various shapes, which can add a whimsical touch to your biscuit experience. Imagine eating a star-shaped biscuit on Christmas morning; it has a certain magical appeal!

The sharp edges of cookie cutters make them perfect for clean cuts, mimicking the efficiency of a dedicated biscuit cutter. However, they can be smaller in diameter, so keep an eye on the size if you prefer larger biscuits.

Do bear in mind that not all cookie cutters are created equal. Those with intricate designs may not be suitable for biscuit dough, which is denser than cookie dough. Opt for simple, circular designs with smooth edges.

Mason Jar Lid

Now, let’s consider the mason jar lid. It’s sturdy and offers a similar level of comfort as a biscuit cutter, thanks to its circular shape and rigid sides. Plus, if you’re into recycling and repurposing, this option aligns perfectly with a sustainable kitchen philosophy.

However, the downside is that mason jar lids can have a relatively sharp edge on the inside, which could potentially be a safety hazard. Make sure to handle it with care.

Another minor hiccup is that the mason jar lid, being smaller, might produce smaller biscuits. But if you have mason jars of varying sizes, you can pick the one that best suits your biscuit size preference.

Read More  7 Best Substitute For Star Anise

Canning Ring

What about a canning ring? It’s already in your kitchen, right beside those mason jars. Canning rings offer a similar experience to mason jar lids but have the added benefit of hollow centers, which make them easier to remove from the cut dough.

The primary downside here is that canning rings are not as sturdy as dedicated biscuit cutters or mason jar lids. They can sometimes bend or warp under pressure.

Also, canning rings usually come in standard sizes, so your biscuits might be somewhat uniform. But who said uniformity was a bad thing? Especially when it brings with it the delicious smell of freshly baked biscuits.

Sharp Knife

Now, let’s discuss the use of a sharp knife. This tool offers a lot of control but requires a steady hand. You can essentially cut your biscuit dough into any shape or size you like, giving you complete freedom.

The downside is that this method can be time-consuming. Also, unless you’re skilled at it, you may end up with unevenly sized biscuits.

Pro tip: For cleaner edges, dip the knife in flour before each cut. This helps reduce stickiness and ensures that your biscuits separate easily.

Wine Glass

The elegant wine glass makes the list too! Similar to a regular glass or mug, a wine glass can offer a more sophisticated alternative. Its longer stem provides excellent grip, allowing for easier and more precise cuts.

However, wine glasses are generally more fragile and can break under pressure. Also, the edge is usually not sharp, leading to less-than-perfect shapes.

A handy tip here is to use wine glasses with a thicker base, as they offer more stability. And just like the regular glass or mug, dipping the edge in flour can make a big difference.


Believe it or not, a spoon can be a viable option. It’s unconventional, yes, but spoons allow you to create rustic, hand-shaped biscuits. This method works best with softer dough that can be easily shaped.

Read More  7 Best Substitutes for Blue Cheese

The primary downside is that this method may not yield perfectly circular biscuits. But if you’re in a pinch and have nothing else, a spoon can save the day.

The trick is to use the spoon to carve out a small amount of dough, shape it into a ball, and then flatten it to your desired thickness. Perfect for those who appreciate an artisan touch to their meals.

Aluminum Foil Mold

Last but not least, an aluminum foil mold. If you’re the creative type who enjoys DIY solutions, you’ll love this one. You can shape the foil into the size and thickness you desire, giving you complete control over your biscuit’s dimensions.

The downside is that this method can be a bit labor-intensive and might not produce perfectly round shapes.

However, it does offer an exciting project for those who enjoy a hands-on approach to cooking. Make sure to press the edges of your foil mold thoroughly to avoid any sharp corners.


What’s more personal than using your own hands? If you don’t mind getting a little dirty, this is as authentic as it gets. Simply take a portion of dough, roll it into a ball, and flatten it to create your biscuit.

The obvious downside is that this won’t yield a perfectly uniform biscuit. Also, temperature and cleanliness are factors to consider; make sure your hands are clean and cool to prevent the dough from sticking.

Despite these minor setbacks, the hands-on method gives you a personal connection to your food, as each biscuit becomes a unique creation of its own.


There you have it—the ultimate guide to biscuit cutter substitutes! From everyday household items to DIY solutions, the options are as limitless as your imagination. So the next time you find yourself without a biscuit cutter, remember that necessity is the mother of invention. Who knows, you might even discover that you prefer one of these alternatives to the traditional biscuit cutter. Happy baking!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *